We just finished up our first season in our League and had four trophies awarded. 3 of the trophies looked like this one:

One for "Top Money Winner" (Green), one for "Player of the Year" (Black), & one for "Mr. Consistency" (Red).
For our TOC, we got a big perpetual cup trophy that went to the winner. His name and the year will be engraved on the base and each year it will pass to a different player. Here's a pic of the winner and his trophy:

Unfortunately, it wasn't me this year

Starting next year, I'm going to be giving each tourey winner one of these pins (the black pin)

Just as an extra little something for the win to brag with, plus we have extra cash since we don't need to re-buy the TOC trophy.
The players loved the trophies and it seemed like some were more interested in winning those than the money! One player who busted out of the TOC tried to buy his way back in just to win the trophy. He offered one of the players still in about half of the 1st place prize from his own wallet. He was half joking, but I think he really wanted to do it.
If you're interested, the small trophies and the pins I got from
http://www.trophies2go.com. The Big Cup I got from
http://trophycentral.com. Both had excellent service and fast delivery times.